List

Shelter Island, NY residential land for sale

118 properties

Explore land for sale in Shelter Island, NY for more listings.

17.4 Acres of Land for Sale in Orient, New York

28 days

$2,375,00017.4 acres

Suffolk County

Orient, NY 11957

17.6 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

21 days

$15,995,00017.6 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 11 ba9,906 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

1.84 Acres of Residential Land for Sale in Water Mill, New York

2 months ago

$5,395,0001.84 acres

Suffolk County

Water Mill, NY 11976

5.2 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

31 days ago

$10,795,0005.2 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 8.5 ba10,000 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

5.24 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Marion, New York

59 days ago

$5,750,0005.24 acres

Suffolk County2 bd, 3 ba2,622 sq ft

East Marion, NY 11939

2 months ago

$4,995,0001.84 acres

Suffolk County

Water Mill, NY 11976

2 months ago

$5,195,0001.84 acres

Suffolk County

Water Mill, NY 11976

2 months ago

$5,295,0001.84 acres

Suffolk County

Water Mill, NY 11976

5.1 Acres of Land with Home for Lease in Sagaponack, New York

40 days ago

$150,000/mo5.1 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 3.5 ba3,667 sq ft

Sagaponack, NY 11962

3.65 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in North Haven, New York

11 days

$15,995,0003.65 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 8.5 ba8,960 sq ft

North Haven, NY 11963

45.8 Acres of Agricultural & Residential Land for Sale in Southold, New York

15 days

$4,300,00045.8 acres

Suffolk County

Southold, NY 11971

7 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

2 months ago

$5,295,0007 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 7 ba7,178 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

4.1 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

48 days ago

$8,275,0004.1 acres

Suffolk County9 bd, 11 ba9,233 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

4.62 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Bridgehampton, New York

3 months ago

$13,925,0004.62 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 5.5 ba6,087 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11976

2.37 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in North Haven, New York

11 days

$10,990,0002.37 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 8 ba8,030 sq ft

North Haven, NY 11963

2.8 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

47 days ago

$8,200,0002.8 acres

Suffolk County9 bd, 8.5 ba4,535 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

4.62 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

13 days

$8,495,0004.62 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 5.5 ba9,500 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

5.4 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Wainscott, New York

3 months ago

$18,950,0005.4 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 12 ba13,400 sq ft

Wainscott, NY 11975

6.8 Acres of Land with Home for Lease in Peconic, New York

4 months ago

$18,000/mo6.8 acres

Suffolk County3 bd, 3 ba3,100 sq ft

Peconic, NY 11958

4.3 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Sag Harbor, New York

54 days ago

$5,650,0004.3 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 8.5 ba— sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

3.58 Acres of Land with Home for Lease in East Marion, New York

2 months ago

$15,000/mo3.58 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 2.5 ba2,440 sq ft

East Marion, NY 11939

1 Acre of Residential Land for Sale in Water Mill, New York

6 days

$1,749,0001 acre

Suffolk County

Water Mill, NY 11976

33.7 Acres of Land for Sale in Water Mill, New York

2 months ago

$5,495,00033.7 acres

Suffolk County

Water Mill, NY 11976

3.88 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Greenport, New York

4 months ago

$2,400,0003.88 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 2 ba2,480 sq ft

Greenport, NY 11944

2 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Sag Harbor, New York

41 days ago

$4,999,0002 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4 ba2,700 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

13.6 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Bridgehampton, New York

32 days ago

$29,500,00013.6 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 6.5 ba6,640 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11932

41 Acres of Land for Sale in Water Mill, New York

2 months ago

$25,500,00041 acres

Suffolk County

Water Mill, NY 11976

1.16 Acres of Residential Land for Sale in East Marion, New York

2 months ago

$695,0001.16 acres

Suffolk County

East Marion, NY 11939

2 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Shelter Island, New York

25 days

$5,500,0002 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5.5 ba4,000 sq ft

Shelter Island, NY 11965

1.5 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

30 days ago

$4,995,0001.5 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4.5 ba3,500 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

3.1 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

$1.05m drop • May 2

$9,950,0003.1 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 11.5 ba12,000 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

2.5 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Bridgehampton, New York

3 months ago

$24,995,0002.5 acres

Suffolk County9 bd, 12.5 ba14,880 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11976

2.7 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

3 months ago

$9,995,0002.7 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 12 ba9,400 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

2.55 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

3 months ago

$2,500,0002.55 acres

Suffolk County3 bd, 3 ba3,000 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

3.1 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Greenport, New York

5 months ago

$1,499,0003.1 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 1.5 ba1,880 sq ft

Greenport, NY 11944

8.65 Acres of Residential Land for Sale in Southold, New York

20 days

$1,799,0008.65 acres

Suffolk County

Southold, NY 11971

0.55 Acres of Residential Land for Sale in Greenport, New York

8 months ago

$549,0000.55 acres

Suffolk County

Greenport, NY 11944

3.6 Acres of Land with Home for Lease in Sag Harbor, New York

4 months ago

$30,000/mo3.6 acres

Suffolk County3 bd, 3 ba1,904 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

1.84 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Sag Harbor, New York

2 months ago

$12,995,0001.84 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 6 ba4,868 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

27 Acres of Improved Agricultural Land for Sale in Southold, New York

3 months ago

$9,400,00027 acres

Suffolk County— sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

2 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

$495k drop • Mar 25

$5,500,0002 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 8.5 ba6,388 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

25 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

12 months ago

$67,500,00025 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 12 ba25,000 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11975

1.5 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

21 days

$14,950,0001.5 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 6.5 ba6,380 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

2.48 Acres of Land with Home for Lease in Southold, New York

$600 drop • Mar 31

$4,900/mo2.48 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 2 ba2,000 sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

2 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

34 days ago

$1,590,0002 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 2.5 ba1,512 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

2.55 Acres of Residential Land for Sale in East Hampton, New York

4 months ago

$3,500,0002.55 acres

Suffolk County

East Hampton, NY 11937

6.6 Acres of Land for Sale in East Hampton, New York

$1.1m drop • Feb 19

$5,900,0006.6 acres

Suffolk County

East Hampton, NY 11937

2.1 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Sag Harbor, New York

7 months ago

$4,495,0002.1 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 6 ba5,000 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

4 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

9 months ago

$9,800,0004 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 8.5 ba8,500 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

0.37 Acres of Residential Land for Sale in Sag Harbor, New York

20 months ago

$1,750,0000.37 acres

Suffolk County

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

1-50 of 118 properties

Buying residential land in Shelter Island

Find residential land for sale in Shelter Island, NY including vacant land ready to build, country homes with acreage, golf course lots, and residential homesites.

There are currently 118 residential properties for sale near Shelter Island, with an average listing price of $4,227,600. The average cost to buy is $1,582,186 per acre. Search land for sale in New York to view every property in the state.

Residential land for sale in Shelter Island

Acreage for sale: 13 acres
Average listing age: 191 days
Average list price: $4,227,600
Median list price: $4,445,000
Average property size: 2.7 acres

Map