Shelter Island, NY houses with land for sale

186 properties

For you

Newest

Price: high to low

Price: low to high

Size: large to small

Size: small to large

Updated

Explore land for sale in Shelter Island, NY for more listings.

6 years ago

$30,000/mo2.25 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 3.5 ba • 3,000 sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

2 years ago

$55,000/mo1.69 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5 ba • 3,300 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

5 years ago

$150,000/mo2.6 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5.5 ba • 6,270 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

22 months ago

$90,000/mo1.68 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 4 ba • 3,900 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

11 months ago

$4,859,0001.68 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 8 ba • 8,500 sq ft

Cutchogue, NY 11935

2 years ago

$375,000/mo2.2 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 4 ba • 4,500 sq ft

Sagaponack, NY 11962

16 months ago

$85,000/mo1.84 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4 ba • 4,000 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

3 years ago

$100,000/mo4.38 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4.5 ba • 4,820 sq ft

Southampton, NY 11932

7 months ago

$300,000/mo10 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 7.5 ba • 12,260 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

2 months ago

$1,850,0001.58 acres

Suffolk County3 bd, 3 ba • 2,017 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

14 months ago

$3,195,0001.56 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4 ba • 2,750 sq ft

Sagaponack, NY 11963

8 months ago

$525,000/mo1.84 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 9 ba • 12,500 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11976

14 months ago

$150,000/mo2.4 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 7.5 ba • 9,444 sq ft

North Haven, NY 11963

20 months ago

$95,000/mo2 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4.5 ba • 4,500 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

2 years ago

$165,000/mo1.65 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 11 ba • 12,000 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11976

5 months ago

$50,000/mo2.12 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5 ba • 2,842 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

19 months ago

$102,857/mo1.69 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 5.5 ba • 4,737 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

7 years ago

$135,000/mo3.5 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 8.5 ba • 9,500 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

6 years ago

$150,000/mo4.6 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 4.5 ba • 5,000 sq ft

Southampton, NY 11968

$300k drop • May 13

$6,495,0001.8 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 9.5 ba • 9,730 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

14 months ago

$7,900,0001.9 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 5.5 ba • 6,212 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

3 months ago

$30,000/mo2 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 3.5 ba • 2,000 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

46 days ago

$495,000/mo1.7 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 7.5 ba • — sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

18 months ago

$180,000/mo1.7 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 4 ba • 3,000 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11932

48 days ago

$19,950,0001.7 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 7.5 ba • — sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

2 months ago

$3,499,0002.2 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 3.5 ba • 3,856 sq ft

Shelter Island, NY 11964

12 months ago

$3,295,0001.9 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4 ba • 3,940 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

6 years ago

$165,000/mo2 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 5.5 ba • 5,700 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

5 years ago

$91,071/mo2 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5 ba • 4,872 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

8 months ago

$150,000/mo2 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 4.5 ba • 6,144 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

3 years ago

$60,000/mo1.54 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 3 ba • 3,200 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

15 months ago

$290,322/mo2.79 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 7.5 ba • 8,000 sq ft

Sagaponack, NY 11963

3 years ago

$55,000/mo1.9 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 3.5 ba • 3,800 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11932

5 years ago

$625,000/mo2 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 10 ba • 11,000 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

14 months ago

$3,495,0001.7 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 3 ba • 2,500 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

6 days

$3,800/mo22.5 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 2 ba • 2,000 sq ft

Orient, NY 11957

4 years ago

$55,000/mo1.6 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 4.5 ba • 2,800 sq ft

Wainscott, NY 11937

14 months ago

$171,428/mo2.1 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 3 ba • 4,500 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

14 months ago

$300,000/mo2 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 5.5 ba • 6,200 sq ft

Southampton, NY 11968

20 years ago

$50,000/mo1.8 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 3 ba • 1,955 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

11 months ago

$14,995,0009 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 11 ba • 9,000 sq ft

Southampton, NY 11976

55 days ago

$64,999/mo2.5 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 2.5 ba • 2,400 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

19 months ago

$250,000/mo1.6 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 7.5 ba • 5,111 sq ft

Sagaponack, NY 11962

2 months ago

$45,000/mo3.66 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5 ba • 4,000 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

6 months ago

$2,799,0002.29 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 7 ba • 5,600 sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

2 years ago

$100,000/mo2 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 6.5 ba • 4,600 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

2 years ago

$26,086/mo2.15 acres

Suffolk County1 bd, 1 ba • 1,000 sq ft

Sagaponack, NY 11962

4 years ago

$40,277/mo1.7 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5.5 ba • — sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

35 days ago

$64,999/mo1.62 acres

Suffolk County3 bd, 3.5 ba • 2,000 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

8 months ago

$45,600/mo2 acres

Suffolk County3 bd, 3 ba • 1,600 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

101-150 of 186 properties