List

Shelter Island, NY houses with land for sale

50 properties

Explore land for sale in Shelter Island, NY and houses with land for sale in New York for more nearby properties.

8.1 Acres of Improved Land for Sale in Shelter Island, New York

6 months ago

$4,495,0008.12 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5 ba • 4,478 sq ft

Shelter Island, NY 11964

2.2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Shelter Island, New York

4 days

$6,500,0002.2 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 7 ba • 4,941 sq ft

Shelter Island, NY 11964

6 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Shelter Island, New York

$500k drop • Apr 18

$4,350,0006 acres

Suffolk County3 bd, 2 ba • 1,784 sq ft

Shelter Island, NY 11964

2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Shelter Island, New York

6 months ago

$9,750,0002 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 6 ba • 6,000 sq ft

Shelter Island, NY 11964

10.9 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

5 months ago

$6,495,00011 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 8 ba • 9,000 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

6.2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Sag Harbor, New York

2 months ago

$3,995,0006.2 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4 ba • 4,200 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

13.9 Acres of Recreational Land with Home for Sale in Wainscott, New York

39 days ago

$45,000,00014 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 11 ba • 10,000 sq ft

Wainscott, NY 11975

4 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

2 months ago

$4,495,0004 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 7 ba • 5,000 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

30.8 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Southold, New York

2 months ago

$2,899,00031 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 2 ba • 2,000 sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

7.1 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

$200k drop • Apr 27

$7,495,0007 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 8 ba • — sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

18.9 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

1 day

$15,995,00019 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 10 ba • 10,500 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Southold, New York

58 days ago

$3,950,0002 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5 ba • — sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

5.8 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

14 months ago

$6,995,0005.8 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 6 ba • 6,150 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

7 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

4 months ago

$11,995,0007 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 12 ba • — sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

3.3 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Southold, New York

pending

Under contract

$7,395,0003.28 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 6 ba • — sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

3.1 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

pending

Under contract

$3,500,0003 acres

Suffolk County3 bd, 3 ba • 2,400 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

3 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

5 months ago

$2,395,0003 acres

Suffolk County3 bd, 3 ba • 1,381 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

5 months ago

$2,195,0003 acres

Suffolk County1 bd, 1 ba • 948 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

4.2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Southold, New York

4 days

$3,950,0004.2 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 6 ba • 4,200 sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Southampton, New York

$255k drop • Apr 23

$5,995,0002 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 11 ba • 6,918 sq ft

Southampton, NY 11968

13.1 Acres of Land with Home for Sale in Southold, New York

12 months ago

$3,600,00013 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 5 ba • — sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

5.1 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Southampton, New York

1 day

$2,800,0005 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4 ba • 4,148 sq ft

Southampton, NY 11968

2.2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Southold, New York

10 days

$3,895,0002.23 acres

Suffolk County3 bd, 3 ba • — sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Sag Harbor, New York

44 days ago

$4,600,0002 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5 ba • 3,200 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

4.9 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Sag Harbor, New York

$145k drop • May 3

$7,350,0004.88 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 10 ba • 8,635 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

2.1 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Bridgehampton, New York

7 months ago

$8,500,0002 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 7 ba • 7,168 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11932

2.4 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

8 months ago

$10,495,0002.38 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4 ba • 5,039 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

3.1 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Sagaponack, New York

4 months ago

$15,995,0003.1 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 3 ba • — sq ft

Sagaponack, NY 11962

$100k drop • May 2

$4,295,0002 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 6 ba • 6,100 sq ft

Southampton, NY 11968

2.8 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Sagaponack, New York

26 days

$12,495,0002.8 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 6 ba • 3,329 sq ft

Sagaponack, NY 11962

5 months ago

$4,590,0005.8 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 4 ba • 2,329 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11976

2.1 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Southampton, New York

37 days ago

$2,495,0002.1 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 5 ba • 4,218 sq ft

Southampton, NY 11968

2.2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

$650k drop • Mar 13

$3,300,0002.18 acres

Suffolk County4 bd, 5 ba • 4,200 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

3 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Sagaponack, New York

20 months ago

$27,500,0003 acres

Suffolk County11 bd, 17 ba • 20,014 sq ft

Sagaponack, NY 11962

4.9 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

$800k drop • May 1

$9,750,0004.89 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 11 ba • 9,460 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11968

2.5 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Water Mill, New York

3 months ago

$6,695,0002.5 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 9 ba • 8,500 sq ft

Water Mill, NY 11968

2.4 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Southold, New York

5 months ago

$3,100,0002.44 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 5 ba • 4,051 sq ft

Southold, NY 11971

2.3 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Sag Harbor, New York

$250k drop • Apr 28

$5,500,0002.27 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 6 ba • 5,070 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

8 months ago

$24,500,0002 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 10 ba • 7,000 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

3.5 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

12 months ago

$5,500,0003.5 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 5 ba • 5,500 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

4.1 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

2 months ago

$6,950,0004 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 8 ba • — sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

2 months ago

$7,950,0004 acres

Suffolk County9 bd, 12 ba • 9,232 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

2.1 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in East Hampton, New York

5 months ago

$15,000,0002.14 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 6 ba • 5,500 sq ft

East Hampton, NY 11937

3 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Bridgehampton, New York

42 days ago

$9,250,0003 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 9 ba • 10,195 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11976

4 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Bridgehampton, New York

$205k drop • Mar 28

$5,495,0004 acres

Suffolk County5 bd, 7 ba • 5,000 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11932

17 days

$12,500,0002 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 11 ba • 9,580 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11963

5.9 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Wainscott, New York

pending

Under contract

$4,999,0006 acres

Suffolk County6 bd, 6 ba • — sq ft

Wainscott, NY 11975

2.5 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Bridgehampton, New York

42 days ago

$8,950,0002.5 acres

Suffolk County2 bd, 1 ba • 980 sq ft

Bridgehampton, NY 11932

$700k drop • Feb 6

$13,995,0002.8 acres

Suffolk County7 bd, 6 ba • 5,040 sq ft

Sagaponack, NY 11962

3.2 Acres of Residential Land with Home for Sale in Sag Harbor, New York

2 months ago

$7,495,0003.2 acres

Suffolk County8 bd, 10 ba • 10,000 sq ft

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Buying houses with land in Shelter Island

Find houses with land for sale in Shelter Island, NY including cheap rural homes with acreage, small country homes, and spacious scenic properties with a house.

The 50 matching properties for sale near Shelter Island have an average listing price of $6,273,750 and price per acre of $1,369,814. For more nearby real estate, explore land for sale in Shelter Island, NY.

Homes with land for sale in Shelter Island

Acreage for sale: 18 acres
Average listing age: 166 days
Average purchase price: $6,273,750
Median purchase price: $5,497,500
Average property size: 4.6 acres

View map