Skip to main content
Skip to navigation
Properties
Find agent
Post property
Log in
•
Sign up
Search here
List
Shelter Island Heights, NY land for sale
Price
Size
Tags
Save
109 properties
For you
Newest
Price: high to low
Price: low to high
Size: large to small
Size: small to large
Updated
11 days
$545,000
0.67 acres
Suffolk County
Greenport, NY 11944
8 months ago
$2,700,000
3.14 acres
Suffolk County
5 bd, 4 ba
•
— sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
20 months ago
$9,500,000
10 acres
Suffolk County
5 bd, 7 ba
•
10,878 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
$101k drop • Mar 23
$999,000
0.88 acres
Suffolk County
East Hampton, NY 11937
11 months ago
$1,350,000
1.75 acres
Suffolk County
3 bd, 1.5 ba
•
2,000 sq ft
Southold, NY 11971
17 months ago
$4,495,000
2.2 acres
Suffolk County
5 bd, 5.5 ba
•
5,260 sq ft
Southampton, NY 11968
5 months ago
$695,000
1 acre
Suffolk County
Shelter Island, NY 11964
4 months ago
$25,000/mo
2.75 acres
Suffolk County
3 bd, 1 ba
•
1,250 sq ft
Peconic, NY 11958
8 months ago
$15,000,000
103 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 5.5 ba
•
5,500 sq ft
Orient, NY 11957
10 months ago
$1,750,000
1 acre
Suffolk County
Wainscott, NY 11975
$200k drop • Mar 20
$6,795,000
1.8 acres
Suffolk County
8 bd, 9.5 ba
•
9,730 sq ft
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
13 months ago
$1,499,000
5.25 acres
Suffolk County
Southold, NY 11971
44 days ago
$160,000/mo
5.3 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 3.5 ba
•
— sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
$405k drop • Jan 27
$5,350,000
1.68 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 8 ba
•
8,500 sq ft
Cutchogue, NY 11935
8 months ago
$3,495,000
9.17 acres
Suffolk County
Southampton, NY 11976
11 months ago
$3,195,000
1.56 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 4 ba
•
2,750 sq ft
Sagaponack, NY 11963
$100k drop • Feb 15
$1,895,000
1.63 acres
Suffolk County
Wainscott, NY 11937
10 months ago
$4,445,000
2.16 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 7 ba
•
5,622 sq ft
Shelter Island, NY 11964
27 days
$2,950,000
1.6 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 3.5 ba
•
3,600 sq ft
Sagaponack, NY 11963
10 months ago
$2,000,000
11.6 acres
Suffolk County
Cutchogue, NY 11935
19 months ago
$6,995,000
2.7 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 6.5 ba
•
9,770 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
5 months ago
$1,500,000
1.24 acres
Suffolk County
East Hampton, NY 11937
11 months ago
$7,900,000
1.9 acres
Suffolk County
7 bd, 5.5 ba
•
6,212 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
8 months ago
$12,995,000
9 acres
Suffolk County
8 bd, 11 ba
•
9,000 sq ft
Southampton, NY 11976
15 months ago
$3,995,000
0.24 acres
Suffolk County
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
18 months ago
$3,395,000
2.33 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 4 ba
•
3,795 sq ft
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
2 years ago
$1,600,000
2 acres
Suffolk County
Southold, NY 11971
11 months ago
$3,495,000
1.7 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 3 ba
•
2,500 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
11 months ago
$5,495,000
1.5 acres
Suffolk County
5 bd, 5.5 ba
•
4,800 sq ft
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
14 months ago
$799,000
2.29 acres
Suffolk County
Southold, NY 11971
6 months ago
$135,000/mo
2 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 4.5 ba
•
3,550 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
2 years ago
$650,000
0.96 acres
Suffolk County
East Marion, NY 11939
12 months ago
$1,500,000
1.5 acres
Suffolk County
Water Mill, NY 11976
9 months ago
$6,500/mo
1.7 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 3 ba
•
2,800 sq ft
Greenport, NY 11944
19 months ago
$1,795,000
1.1 acres
Suffolk County
East Hampton, NY 11937
Pending
Under contract
$1,259,000
2.87 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 2 ba
•
2,075 sq ft
Orient, NY 11957
Pending
Under contract
$399,000
7.13 acres
Suffolk County
Southold, NY 11971
4 months ago
$30,000/mo
1.5 acres
Suffolk County
5 bd, 4.5 ba
•
3,600 sq ft
Southold, NY 11971
8 days
$4,850,000
0.51 acres
Suffolk County
6 bd, 4.5 ba
•
— sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
Pending
Under contract
$2,100,000
2 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 3.5 ba
•
3,388 sq ft
Water Mill, NY 11976
20 months ago
$2,995,000
Suffolk County
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Pending
Under contract
$499,999
1.84 acres
Suffolk County
Cutchogue, NY 11935
$200k drop • Mar 3
$2,799,000
2.29 acres
Suffolk County
8 bd, 7 ba
•
5,600 sq ft
Southold, NY 11971
6 months ago
$2,000,000
3.1 acres
Suffolk County
3 bd, 2.5 ba
•
1,904 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
Pending
Under contract
$595,000
1 acre
Suffolk County
East Marion, NY 11939
Pending
Under contract
$579,000
0.35 acres
Suffolk County
Greenport, NY 11944
Pending
Under contract
$2,700,000
2.3 acres
Suffolk County
4 bd, 4 ba
•
3,040 sq ft
East Hampton, NY 11937
Pending
Under contract
$35,500,000
104 acres
Suffolk County
11 bd, 13 ba
•
— sq ft
Peconic, NY 11958
Pending
Under contract
$325,000
0.14 acres
Suffolk County
Greenport, NY 11944
Pending
Under contract
$4,350,000
11.8 acres
Suffolk County
East Hampton, NY 11975
1
2
3
51-100 of 109 properties
Map