Skip to main contentSkip to navigation
1 / 36
Images
Map
Street

Residential Land with Home for Sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York

11 Sunnyside Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

$5,500,000
2 acres
Active
ago
Est $34,465/mo

Sited on one of the highest elevations in Shelter Island Heights & within easy reach of the island's most coveted points of interest, this exquisitely imagined 4-bedroom, 5.5-bathroom brand-new residence on 2 quiet acres offers resort-style luxury living in an oasis of masterful contemporary design. A creation of developer Angelo Varischetti and the award-winning team at WE+ Architecture & Design, there is nothing else like it on Shelter Island. The expansive living areas are elegant and spacious, offering ideal settings for both relaxation and entertainment. There are floor-to-ceiling window walls everywhere you look, perfectly framing winter big water views and nature vistas. A state-of-the-art chef's kitchen features Wolfe, Sub-Zero, and Miele appliances, Victoria Falls quartzite countertops and ample space for culinary pursuits. Refined details and stunning finishes like Phylrich bathroom fixtures, Toto toilets, Cortizo windows, micro-topping concrete floors and datum walls are found throughout. All millwork and cabinetry is individually created and stain grade. Each bedroom boasts its own ensuite bathroom with custom skylight and Taj Mahal stone surfaces, ensuring privacy for guests as well as direct access to the landscaped grounds, including the 50x14 heated knife-edge Gunite pool with Ipe wood decking, open-air shower and full cabana bath. The outdoor experience is exceptional: an alfresco kitchen and dining area provide a seamless extension of the recreation zone. The lower level offers flexibility with the potential to create a personal gym & wellness area. This home is part of the coveted Shelter Island Heights owners association, which includes access to a members-only beach club, private Har-Tru tennis courts, and organized association events, plus a high quality public water utility. Surrounded by lush greenery and just moments from destinations like Shelter Island Country Club golf course, Sunset Beach, the Pridwin & Leon 1909, this home promises a lifestyle of sophisticated leisure. A tranquil, stylish Shelter Island escape awaits.

4,000
Sq feet
4
Beds
5
Full baths
1
1/2 bath
2026
Built

Location

Street address
11 Sunnyside Ave
Elevation
167 feet
Coordinates
41.0768, -72.3603

Property details

Acreage
2 acres
MLS #
MyStateMLS 11630032
Posted

Parcels

  • 0700-007.000-02-000.004

Details and features

Listing

Type
Residential
Subtype
Single Family Residence

Exterior

Parking
Garage

Structure

Style
Modern
Stories
1
Heating
Fireplace(s)
Cooling
Central Air

Interior

Rooms
Basement, Bathroom x 5, Bedroom x 4, Den, Kitchen, Living Room, Media Room
Flooring
Hardwood
Appliances
Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer
Features
Walk-In Closet

Listing history

DateEventPriceChangeSource
Jan 12, 2026New listing$5,500,000MyStateMLS
Subscribe to listing updates

Payment calculator

This 2-acre property is located at 11 Sunnyside Ave in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965. The property is available for sale for $5,500,000. It has a 4,000 sq ft 4 bedroom, 5 bath house built in 2026.

Checked 4 hours ago — Updated

Report listing issue

Copyright (C) 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Contact listing agent Message rules
By submitting, I agree to the terms of use and to be contacted by real estate professionals. Message and data rates may apply.
Contact